Cover crop and P fertilizer management impacts on nutrient cycling capacity and the soil microbial community in a no-till corn-soybean rotation
Date
Authors
Journal Title
Journal ISSN
Volume Title
Publisher
Abstract
Balancing crop nutrient requirements with environmental sustainability remains a critical
challenge in phosphorus (P) management for grain crop production. Phosphorus is commonly a
limited nutrient in crop production, requiring the application of P fertilizer in attempts to increase
plant available P in order to meet crop requirements. However, excess fertilizer applications can
often result in environmental disasters for soil and water quality. Soil health is a concept founded
in the idea of preserving soil as a vital living resource to support plants. Optimizing soil health
helps to preserve soil as a natural resource and allow for sustained crop production. The
implementation of conservation management practices can enhance chemical, physical, and
biological soil health metrics. The impacts that cover crops and phosphorus fertilizer
management have on nutrient cycling and soil health metrics are complex and need further
research.
A study was conducted in Manhattan, KS, at the Kansas agricultural watershed field
laboratory during the years of 2014-2025. The study contained two levels of cover crop
management: no cover (NC) and cover crop (CC) and three P fertilizer management scenarios:
2014-2019 included no phosphorus (NP), spring injected (SI), and fall surface broadcast (FB)
applications with P fertilizer rates in SI and FB determined with a “build” recommendation. The
SI and FB plots received 61 kg P2O5 ha-1 annually. The P management goal changed in 2020
2022 and aimed to maintain P in the SI plots and begin the drawdown of P in the FB plots. The
maintenance P management approach included 55 kg P2O5 ha-1 applied to the SI plots, while
both the drawdown P approach in the former FB plots and the NP control plots received no P
fertilizer during these years. At this point, P fertilizer treatment labels shifted to no phosphorus
(NP), sufficiency (SUF), and build and maintain (BAM). This shift in treatment labels better
reflects the goals of each P management scenario from 2023 to 2025. During the years of 2023
2025, the P managements goals were to follow the Kansas State University build and maintain or
sufficiency recommendations. In 2023, the SI plots (BAM) received 53 kg P2O5 ha-1, SUF plots
received 23 kg P2O5 ha-1, and the NP plots continued to remain a no P control. The experiment
site was managed in a no-till, corn (Zea mays L.) and soybean (Glycine max (L.) Merr.) crop
rotation with soybeans planted on even years and corn planted on odd years. Soil samples were
collected at 0-5 cm four times during the growing season, and the times were labelled as follows:
SP/T0, T1, T2, and FL. The SP/T0 sampling was taken after cover crop termination and before
planting, T1 and T2 were taken during the crop growth period and fall (FL) sampling took place
after grain crop harvest. The soil health indicators analyzed included: soil respiration, autoclaved
citrate extractable (ACE) protein, permanganate oxidizable carbon (POXC), dissolved total N
(DTN), inorganic N (NO3-N and NH4-N), dissolved organic N (DON), dissolved organic C
(DOC), microbial biomass carbon (MBC), microbial biomass nitrogen (MBN), microbial
biomass P (MBP), water extractable P (WEP), and soil enzyme activities (β-D-glucosaminidase,
β-glucosidase, alkaline phosphatase, and acid phosphatase). The soil health indicators were
analyzed for the 2024 soybean and 2025 corn growing seasons. Phospholipid fatty acid (PLFA)
analysis was also analyzed for soybean years 2018, 2020, 2022, and 2024. This study aimed to
assess how cover crops and P fertilizer management impacts soil health indicators that assess
different nutrient pools as well as the size, activity, diversity, and community abundance of the
soil biological community in a no-till, corn-soybean rotation.
Sampling time had a notable effect on many soil health indicators evaluated, which is
expected as the soil microbial community is susceptible to environmental conditions which can
change within a growing season and between different years. Additionally, nutrient cycling can
be impacted by the present grain crop species and the presence or absence of a cover crop. The
negative effects of CC were seen in NO3-N in 2024 and are likely due to N uptake in the CC.
Autoclavable citrate extractable protein, POXC, MBC, and acid phosphatase were all increased
by the presence of a CC in 2024. A P fertilizer treatment by CC interaction was observed for
alkaline phosphatase, β-D-glucosaminidase, β-glucosidase, and soil respiration in 2024. β
Glucosidase and alkaline phosphatase showed an increase in NP and SUF treatments due to the
CC while soil respiration and β-D-glucosaminidase increased regardless of P fertilizer treatment.
The response from β-glucosidase and alkaline phosphatase can potentially be attributed to the
system having no nutrient limitations. Phosphorus fertilizer treatment had a minimal effect on
soil health indicators overall. Phosphorus fertilizer treatment by time interactions were present in
MBC, MBP, and NH4-N in 2024 as well as in MBN, the ratio of MBN:MBP, and NH4-N in
2025. Nitrogen as MBN, NH4-N, and inorganic N had variable responses depending on year and
sampling time within year. Microbial biomass P and MBC:MBP were also influenced by P
fertilizer treatment alone in 2025 and responded, as expected, with MBP highest in BAM, then
SUF, finally NP having the lowest MBP concentrations.
Microbial abundance quantified by PLFA showed CC had a strong influence. All
microbial groups and total microbial biomass were increased in the CC treatment compared to
the NC treatment in both the SP and FL sampling times. Sampling year influenced the abundance
of microbial groups and total microbial biomass in the SP and FL sampling times. These results
agree with what we would generally expect, because environment largely impacts the microbial
community and the environment tends to be variable from year to year. Phosphorus fertilizer
management had an impact in a 3-way interaction between CC, P fertilizer treatment, and year in
fungi, AMF, and total microbial biomass in the FL. These interactions had variable responses,
but showed increases with the CC treatment compared to NC in different P fertilizer treatments
in different soybean years. Gram-positive bacteria, gram-negative bacteria and eukaryote
abundance were affected by a P fertilizer management by year interaction in the SP. The control
treatment had significantly lower microbial abundance than the BAM treatment that has received
annual P fertilizer applications through time. The DD/SUF sufficiency or drawdown treatment
was not different from either the BAM or NP.
Cover crops have the potential to provide immediate benefits as shown in the SP and
early in-season sampling times as well as legacy effects throughout the growing season as shown
in the FL sampling time. Agreeing with the data previous research has shown, this research
highlights the impact that cover crops can have on the soil microbial community especially when
used in addition to no-till conservation management. Phosphorus fertilizer management provided
variable results, and no generalizations can be made about P fertilizer management decisions in
regard to the soil microbial community.