<link rel="stylesheet" href="styles.cf390c6bfbe7555f.css">

From Policy to Practice: Academic Advisors’ Interpretations of Academic Notice and Student-Facing Support

Loading...
Thumbnail Image

Date

Journal Title

Journal ISSN

Volume Title

Publisher

Abstract

Academic notice is a consequential institutional policy intended to identify academic difficulty and support students’ return to good academic standing. Although research has examined students’ experiences of academic probation and the outcomes of academic recovery interventions, less has been known about how academic advisors interpret and enact academic notice policies in everyday practice. In this basic qualitative study, I examined how academic advisors made sense of the purpose and function of academic notice policies within their institutional context, how they interpreted and enacted those policies in day-to-day advising practice, and how they drew on asset-based, validating, and equity-minded approaches and navigated tensions between institutional expectations and relational care.

The study was grounded in a social constructionist perspective and informed by validation theory and critical theory. Thirteen academic advising professionals from multiple advising units at a large public research university with a decentralized advising structure participated in semi-structured interviews. I analyzed data through first-cycle in vivo coding, second-cycle focused coding, analytic and reflexive memoing, and cross-case comparison and synthesis.

I organized eight cross-case findings into three analytic domains: (a) policy meaning, enactment, and professional judgment; (b) decentralization, consistency, and organizational context; and (c) relational meaning, accountability, and recovery. The findings showed academic notice became practice through local interpretation and operationalization; professional discretion was distributed, stage-dependent, and bounded; policy agency varied by organizational position and responsibility; participants valued consistency in institutional guardrails over uniform procedures; and organizational capacity shaped the forms of support advising units could provide. Participants also described communication and relationships as shaping the meaning of academic notice; relational care and accountability as complementary practices; and academic recovery as developmental and nonlinear while remaining bounded by formal institutional measures of good standing. The findings position academic notice as a policy-shaped, organizationally situated, professionally enacted, and relationally mediated institutional practice. The findings suggest that improving academic notice requires attention not only to formal policy but also to organizational capacity, professional judgment, decision authority, communication practices, relational support, and the conditions under which advisors enact policy with students.

Description

Keywords

Academic advising, Academic notice, Policy enactment, Advisor sensemaking, Equity-minded advising, Academic recovery

Graduation Month

December

Degree

Doctor of Philosophy

Department

Department of Special Education, Counseling and Student Affairs

Major Professor

Christy D. Craft

Date

Type

Dissertation

Citation

Endorsement

Review

Supplemented By

Referenced By