<link rel="stylesheet" href="styles.cf390c6bfbe7555f.css">
dc.contributor.authorSchumacher, Jacob
dc.date.accessioned2026-11-17T19:39:44Z
dc.date.graduationmonthDecember
dc.date.issued2026
dc.description.abstractThis dissertation focuses on strategies to improve cattle welfare by evaluating potential pain management products for use during painful management procedures, and exploring pain detection techniques that could aid in reliably evaluating the efficacy of pain management products. The first chapter consists of a systematic literature review that evaluates the reliability of lying and standing behaviors as an indicator of pain in cattle, and describes trends in these behaviors to help future researchers make inferences from their data. The next three chapters evaluate products that could potentially reduce pain during castration and disbudding in calves through an alternative castration device (Chapter 2), maternal appeasing substance analog (Chapter 3), and a lidocaine-infused castration band (Chapter 4). The last chapter (Chapter 5) of this dissertation evaluates the ability of machine learning to detect painful animals through the use of short videos of cattle faces. Review of 16 relevant articles on lying and standing behavior as an indicator of pain after castration suggests that these outcomes can be a reliable indicator of pain or discomfort. Several studies showed that surgically castrated calves stand for significantly longer than non-castrated control calves within the first 4 days post-castration. Surgically castrated calves may also perform a greater frequency of bouts on the day of castration compared to controls, which could be an indication of restlessness. Regarding band castration, multiple studies showed that band-castrated calves perform a significantly greater frequency of bouts than control calves on the day of castration. In the following weeks, band-castrated calves stood significantly more than control calves. After both surgical and band castration, studies that used accelerometers were the most successful in detecting statistically significant differences in standing and lying behavior between castrated calves and non-castrated control calves. Both studies that analyzed accelerometer data as a difference from baseline values were able to detect significant treatment differences in standing behavior, highlighting the potential benefits of this method of data analysis. Overall, this review found lying and standing outcomes to be useful indicators of pain or discomfort, and was able to establish trends in these outcomes after surgical and band castration. A randomized, blinded, controlled pilot study was conducted to determine the viability of an alternative castration device, called the ClipFitter, in cattle and its effects on pain and welfare. Twelve intact male beef-dairy cross calves were assigned to 1 of 3 treatment groups: castration with ClipFitter (CLIP; n=4), castration with rubber ring band (BAND; n=4), or no castration (SHAM; n=4). Calves’ plasma cortisol, Substance P, lie/stand behavior, and infrared thermography were assessed at multiple timepoints. No significant differences were detected in plasma cortisol, Substance P, lying and standing behavior, and infrared thermography between CLIP and BAND calves within 7 days post-castration. While the viability of the ClipFitter for castration of calves was demonstrated to be promising, the study was unable to find differences in pain measures that could correlate to a negative state of welfare. Lying and standing outcomes suggest that both ClipFitter and rubber band castration cause acute discomfort or pain, as determined by differences in the average duration of lying and standing bouts. Scrotal IRT outcomes suggest that the ClipFitter reduces blood flow to the scrotum at a level indistinguishable from band castration, implying that the ClipFitter could be potentially viable for calf castration. Overall, the castration effectiveness of the ClipFitter and its implications on chronic pain and animal welfare requires further research that follows calves for a longer period post-castration. A second randomized blinded controlled trial was conducted to determine if a single topical dose of a maternal appeasing substance analog, alone, or in combination with local anesthesia, with or without systemic analgesia would provide extended pain and stress relief to calves after disbudding and surgical castration. The calves’ substance P, plasma cortisol, mechanical nociception threshold, infrared thermography, performance, lie and stand activity, behavior, and gait were evaluated at multiple timepoints. No significant differences in infrared thermography, performance, lie and stand activity, and behavior outcomes were observed between treatments (P>0.05). While Substance P, plasma cortisol, mechanical nociception threshold, and kinetic gait analysis differed amongst some treatment groups, no significant differences were observed between treatment groups that received or did not receive the maternal appeasing substance immediately before castration and disbudding. These results suggest that administering a maternal appeasing substance in addition to other analgesic and anesthetic drugs is neither more or less effective at pain mitigation than lidocaine alone in Holstein calves undergoing surgical castration and cautery disbudding. The last randomized blinded controlled trial aimed to evaluate pain mitigation and behavior in beef-dairy and Holstein calves castrated with either lidocaine-loaded or standard bands. Calves’ average daily gain, lying and standing activity, kinetic gait analysis, plasma cortisol, and potential pain-related behaviors were analyzed over a 28-day post-treatment period. Lying and standing activity outcomes showed a significant effect of breed for the number of standing bouts per day, with the BOD group transitioning from lying to standing more frequently than the HOL group, but this difference was considered biologically insignificant. Gait outcomes showed a treatment × time interaction for gait velocity and gait distance, with the CON group increasing over time. However, no gait outcome differed between LLB and CON groups at any time point. Neither treatment or breed had an effect on plasma cortisol, performance, or video monitoring behavior outcomes (P > 0.05). Overall, this study was unable to find differences in pain outcomes between calves that were castrated with either a lidocaine-loaded or standard band. Lastly, observational data was collected to evaluate the performance of 2 video-based convolutional neural network architectures using short videos of the face for automated pain detection in beef cattle, and to determine the optimal view of the face by comparing model performance between lateral and front views of cattle faces. A total of 247 short videos of cattle faces, ranging between 1 to 2 seconds, were classified as Pain (n = 143) and No Pain (n = 104) based on castration performed at feedyard arrival. Two convolutional neural network architectures were used to predict pain status among 3 datasets: combined view (front and lateral view videos of the face), front view only, and lateral view only. The front view dataset was able to identify over half of truly painful animals while minimizing false positive classifications, which could have useful clinical applications. Models using the front view dataset showed significantly better discriminatory ability compared to the lateral view dataset, with the greatest ROC-AUC reaching 0.75, indicating that facial expressions visualized from the front may contain more information on pain status. Overall, this study indicated that automated pain detection using facial analysis with machine learning is feasible for feedyard cattle, and could provide value to feedyard operations and improve cattle welfare. In conclusion, this dissertation could provide valuable information to researchers, veterinarians, and cattle producers on pain management and pain detection strategies to improve cattle welfare. The studies presented in this dissertation advance our knowledge of multiple products intended for pain alleviation, as has demonstrated that video-based machine learning models are a promising tool for pain detection in cattle.
dc.description.advisorMajor Professor Not Listed
dc.description.degreeDoctor of Philosophy
dc.description.departmentDepartment of Anatomy and Physiology
dc.description.levelDoctoral
dc.description.sponsorshipAmerican Association of Bovine Practitioners Fera Diagnostics and Biologicals
dc.identifier.urihttps://hdl.handle.net/2097/47547
dc.language.isoen_US
dc.subjectwelfare
dc.subjectpain
dc.subjectcattle
dc.subjectcastration
dc.titleEvaluation of pain management products and alternative pain detection techniques to improve cattle welfare
dc.typeDissertation

Files

Original bundle

Now showing 1 - 1 of 1
Loading...
Thumbnail Image
Name:
JacobSchumacher2026.pdf
Size:
2.37 MB
Format:
Adobe Portable Document Format

License bundle

Now showing 1 - 1 of 1
Loading...
Thumbnail Image
Name:
license.txt
Size:
1.65 KB
Format:
Item-specific license agreed upon to submission
Description: