<link rel="stylesheet" href="styles.cf390c6bfbe7555f.css">

Teacher efficacy in addressing gaps in foundational reading skills: A narrative case study of lived experiences at a midwestern Title I middle school

Loading...
Thumbnail Image

Date

Journal Title

Journal ISSN

Volume Title

Publisher

Abstract

Kansas requires universal screening for reading difficulties for all students through ninth grade, yet middle-level educators are not held to the same expectations for training and expertise in structured literacy as their elementary counterparts. This narrative case study explored how middle school reading teachers’ lived experiences with reading influenced their efficacy to address gaps in foundational reading skills. Participants were teachers at a midwestern Title I middle school who voluntarily pursued and completed training in structured literacy and the science of reading. The single case study design was informed by narrative inquiry to draw out rich descriptions of lived experiences past and current. Data from two semi-structured interviews and observations were analyzed using in vivo and thematic coding. Findings revealed that firsthand experiences with older struggling readers exposed gaps in initial teacher preparation, motivating participants to seek additional knowledge, mentoring, and training. Participants described these experiences as catalysts for their commitment to knowledge and professional growth. Teachers reported confidence in their current roles to deliver explicit reading instruction. Supportive leadership, shared commitment to literacy, and classrooms where students were valued and celebrated for their effort suggested strong collective efficacy of the group. However, confidence in using data to guide instructional decisions and evaluate student outcomes remained limited and reflected a sense of uncertainty among participants in their current practice. Recommendations for leaders are to sustain and support the state-wide focus on structured literacy and to investigate middle level teacher preparation programs. Building leaders at the middle level should provide a clear picture of reality, establish common instructional expectations for literacy, and protect time for educators to engage in meaningful reflection on practice. Teacher efficacy is complex and shaped by multiple factors. Individual educator commitment is essential, but educators need informed leaders and systemic support to sustain their effort and develop the refined skills necessary to address gaps in foundational reading skills.

Description

Keywords

middle level, reading intervention, structured literacy

Graduation Month

December

Degree

Doctor of Education

Department

Department of Educational Leadership

Major Professor

Donna Augustine-Shaw

Date

Type

Dissertation

Citation

Endorsement

Review

Supplemented By

Referenced By