Adaptive capacity across scales: Context, validation, and the translation of capacity into adaptation
Date
Authors
Journal Title
Journal ISSN
Volume Title
Publisher
Abstract
This dissertation focuses on the capacity of systems and individuals to adapt to environmental stressors. The research contributes to a deeper understanding of adaptive capacity, particularly focusing on how it can be measured, validated, and connected to adaptation across scales. I leverage various conceptual frameworks of, or containing, adaptive capacity (AC) that overlap and apply at different scales. Using Kansas as a case study, I use the Capitals Framework to generate an AC index at the census tract level. This work proposes the use of context-sensitive composite indicators created through an ensemble process to reduce the likelihood of misrepresenting local conditions. I found that adaptive capacity scores varied substantially across construction methods and socioeconomic contexts (metro, non-metro, and farming areas), demonstrating that there is no one-size-fits-all index. In addition, the results suggest that the location and type of system have different exposures and sensitivities that interact with AC. Since agriculture is one of the main drivers of Kansas’s economy and agricultural outputs are significantly influenced by climate shifts, I leverage the Climate Change Vulnerability Framework, which combines exposure, sensitivity, and adaptive capacity, to externally validate the AC index. Keeping individual components disaggregated allows for the assessment of their relationships. I focused on leveraging theoretically expected relationships between them in order to uniquely identify, partition, and disentangle the influence of AC from exposure and sensitivity effects in an effort to conduct an external validation of the adaptive capacity composite indicator. I found that the empirical association between adaptive capacity and sensitivity is context- and outcome-dependent rather than uniformly inverse and is highly localized. These aggregate concepts and models may operate differently within localities, particularly in terms of how individual capacity to adapt translates into action. From the larger scale of county census tracts, at which the composite indicator was created, the dissertation narrows to the individual level to better understand whether and how the capacity to adapt is utilized. In doing so, it remains cognizant that the utilization of adaptive capacity at the individual level is driven not only by access to resources, but also by the willingness to deploy adaptation, which is influenced by psychological and situational factors. At the individual level, I found that knowledge, resilience, perceived control, and confidence were associated with adaptive behaviors, while structural resource constraints, like those captured by the AC index, contributed to an intention–action gap. Together, these findings demonstrate that adaptive capacity provides the potential for adaptation, but outcomes, such as whether that potential reduces sensitivity or produces adaptive action, depend on context, hazard, resource access, psychological factors, and situational factors. By leveraging and connecting frameworks across scales, this work examines adaptive capacity across scales in association with observed impacts and adaptations, highlighting that adaptive capacity is not only a characteristic of a system, but is also expressed through agency and actionable behaviors. In this way, this dissertation contributes to advancing the assessment of adaptive capacity by emphasizing the importance of moving beyond generalized measures toward approaches that are context-sensitive, empirically grounded, and attentive to how capacity is ultimately translated into adaptation.