Exploring mentoring relationships in elementary STEM field placements: lived experiences of preservice and mentor teachers
Date
Authors
Journal Title
Journal ISSN
Volume Title
Publisher
Abstract
Field placements provide preservice teachers with opportunities to take on the work of teaching, but teaching more lessons does not always mean having more opportunities to make instructional decisions. Mentor teachers must support preservice teachers as they learn while also maintaining responsibility for their students and classrooms. Although mentoring has been studied in teacher education, less is understood about how preservice teachers and mentor teachers describe opportunities for reciprocal or collaborative learning within elementary STEM field placements. This basic interpretive qualitative study examined the mentoring experiences of five preservice teachers and two mentor teachers during the Spring 2026 semester. The study was informed by situated learning and Communities of Practice, with attention to participation, mentor authority, and opportunities for shared learning. Data was collected through 13 semi-structured interviews that included interviews with both members of two mentoring pairs. Interview transcripts were analyzed using open coding, pattern coding, and thematic analysis. Nine themes were identified across the three research questions. Preservice teachers described how trust, feedback, and their relationships with mentors shaped their experiences and their willingness to ask questions, try ideas, and take responsibility for instruction. Their accounts showed that increased teaching time did not always provide the same opportunities to make decisions about student learning. Mathematics offered repeated opportunities to discuss student understanding and work through instructional problems, while opportunities for science instruction varied across placements. Mentor teachers described balancing guidance and feedback with decisions about when to step back and allow preservice teachers to work more independently. The two complete pairs also provided examples of how preservice teachers’ observations and instructional ideas became part of shared decision making. The evidence of mentor reflection differed between the two relationships. These findings suggest that opportunities for reciprocal learning can develop within traditional mentoring relationships even when mentors continue to hold greater authority and responsibility. The study highlights the importance of looking beyond the amount of time preservice teachers spend teaching to consider the instructional decisions they are invited to make and the opportunities they have to contribute to the mentoring relationship.