<link rel="stylesheet" href="styles.cf390c6bfbe7555f.css">

Through the kaleidoscope: How millennial women construct leadership pathways in higher education

Loading...
Thumbnail Image

Date

Journal Title

Journal ISSN

Volume Title

Publisher

Abstract

This critical qualitative study examined how millennial women in higher education described and interpreted their pathways toward leadership roles, the ways institutional cultures shaped their persistence, and how institutional structures influenced their decisions about pursuing and sustaining leadership. Guided by the Kaleidoscope Career Model (KCM) and radical feminist theory, the study drew upon semi-structured interviews with nine millennial women working in higher education. Data were analyzed thematically, resulting in six interconnected themes and a collective narrative that represented shared patterns across participants’ experiences. The findings revealed that participants’ careers were nonlinear in shape but neither accidental nor aimless. Participants made deliberate decisions to develop the knowledge and experience necessary for advancement, even when their institutions did not provide visible or reliable pathways between preparation and opportunity. Relationships often bridged this distance by making participants’ readiness visible, explaining unwritten expectations, and creating access to leadership experiences. In many cases, these relationships did not merely support the pathway; they constituted the pathway itself. Participants interpreted persistence as a commitment to sustaining a viable leadership career rather than remaining loyal to a particular position or institution. Persistence could involve staying and resisting limiting conditions, but it could also require leaving when institutional expectations compromised participants’ agency, values, or control over their time. Institutional cultures shaped these decisions through inconsistent advancement practices, uneven access to authority, and reliance on supervisors and other influential individuals to enact policies and create opportunities. Supportive relationships could temporarily make structurally deficient environments sustainable, but they could not compensate indefinitely for unclear pathways or incongruence between institutional practices and participants’ values. The study demonstrates that individual agency and structural constraint operate together in millennial women’s leadership careers. Participants repeatedly constructed viable pathways, but institutions depended heavily on their adaptability and relationships to compensate for unreliable structures. The findings elaborate an organizational interpretation of the Kaleidoscope Career Model by foregrounding how institutional conditions shape participants’ ability to pursue challenge, balance, and authenticity. They also suggest that higher education institutions must create transparent and accessible leadership pathways, recognize relational development as leadership work, and connect preparation to opportunity without requiring exceptional sponsorship.

Description

Keywords

Higher Education, Leadership, Millennial, Women

Graduation Month

December

Degree

Doctor of Philosophy

Department

Department of Special Education, Counseling and Student Affairs

Major Professor

Christy D. Craft

Date

Type

Dissertation

Citation

Endorsement

Review

Supplemented By

Referenced By