Book challenges and bureaucracy in the heartland: A qualitative analysis of librarians’ perceptions of book challenges
Date
Authors
Journal Title
Journal ISSN
Volume Title
Publisher
Abstract
This study aimed to examine public librarians’ perceptions of book challenges, how they resisted book challenges, and why. While the number of book challenges increased drastically in 2021, there is little information regarding librarians’ perceptions of book challenges aside from the perspectives of large organizations. To answer these questions, 23 librarians throughout Kansas, Missouri, and Oklahoma were interviewed to better understand their perceptions of book challenges and how they respond to book challenges. Interviews were then analyzed using a coding strategy derived from grounded theory. The respondents emphasized treating all book challenges as well-intentioned, though they expressed some concern that people challenging books may not be considering the needs of everyone in the community. The librarians strongly opposed resisting book challenges. They emphasized the importance of adhering to policy and having conversations with patrons. Participants claim that their decisions regarding challenges were largely guided by a sense of professional values and a desire to maintain libraries as welcoming spaces for everyone in the community. This project concludes with discussions on librarians’ responses and how those responses tie into literature on bureaucracy and professionalism.