School leadership and student learning: a second-order meta-analysis of domains, dimensions, and practices
Date
Authors
Journal Title
Journal ISSN
Volume Title
Publisher
Abstract
Educational leadership research offers substantial evidence about relationships with student learning, but differences in how leadership is defined and organized make that evidence difficult to consolidate and apply. Drawing on 17 meta-analyses (2001–2026), this second-order synthesis compared relationships between K–12 leadership work and student outcomes at different levels of specificity, with academic achievement as the principal focus. Preserving the original authors’ terminology and construct meanings, the study organized comparable leadership work into 15 dimensions within seven broader domains and examined specific practices separately. Reported associations were expressed as Cohen’s d and combined where appropriate, giving greater weight to estimates based on more contributing primary studies. All 15 dimension estimates were positive (𝑑 = 0.14–0.57). The largest observed associations involved evidence-informed decision making (0.57), resource alignment (0.48), culture and professional community (0.44), professional learning and capacity building (0.43), and establishing shared purpose and direction (0.43). The smallest observed associations involved organizational management and operations (0.23) and instructional monitoring, assessment, and feedback (0.14). Domain estimates ranged from 0.30 to 0.57. Four recurring practices yielded combined estimates, led by setting and sustaining school goals (0.48); 25 additional practice findings were reported individually. Findings concerning school level, school setting, and geography were mixed and did not establish a consistent pattern across leadership dimensions. The proposed model links shared purpose, expertise, collective responsibility, and aligned action around student learning. This synthesis brings greater coherence to accumulated leadership evidence, offering a clearer basis for focusing attention, developing expertise, and aligning resources for school improvement.