Middle school ELL and LD teachers' perceptions of the importance of reading methods

K-REx Repository

Show simple item record

dc.contributor.author Lee, Pei-Yi
dc.date.accessioned 2007-11-26T20:55:48Z
dc.date.available 2007-11-26T20:55:48Z
dc.date.issued 2007-11-26T20:55:48Z
dc.identifier.uri http://hdl.handle.net/2097/429
dc.description.abstract This study is a follow-up to Al-Fadda's (2004) investigation of middle school teacher's perceptions of the importance of reading methods. The primary research question to be addressed in this study was: What are ELL and LD teachers' perceptions of the importance of specific reading strategies for their respective types of students? To address this question the researcher developed a survey with five demographic questions and 44 reading methods based on the framework of the COBRA model developed by Heerman (2002). The researcher administered the survey to public middle and junior high school ELL and LD teachers from Kansas, New Mexico, Oklahoma, and Texas and compared the two groups' perceptions of the importance of several reading strategies. Analysis of the results showed that there was a 60% agreement rate between the two teacher groups (no significant differences) for three of the COBRA goals (background knowledge, comprehension, and study and application) and a 40% difference rate between the two teacher groups (significant differences) for two of the COBRA goals (experiential learning and vocabulary). For the 44 survey items, there was an agreement rate of 82.82%, and a difference rate of 17.18%. The researcher concludes that there were more similarities than differences between ELL teachers' and LD teachers' perceptions of the importance of the surveyed reading methods, however, there were also real differences. The researcher found justification for the belief that ELL and LD teachers should be considered specialist teachers when it comes to rating the relative importance of reading methods. ELL teachers appear to be inclined to use reading methods related to language, experience, and vocabulary methods. The results also reveal that LD teachers appear to be inclined to use reading methods related to intervention strategies with conferencing, coaching, compensatory methods, specific skills development and memory processes. In addition, the researcher noted a large number of methods with small mean differences, showing the certain levels of agreement between the two teacher groups. In terms of the five teacher variables, percentage of ELL students, percentage of low-income students and school enrollment proved to be the least active variables but the teacher variables of teachers' education levels and teachers' experience levels were more active. en
dc.language.iso en_US en
dc.publisher Kansas State University en
dc.subject Curriculum and Instruction en
dc.subject Reading Methods en
dc.subject ELL or English Language Learner en
dc.subject LD or Learning Disability en
dc.subject Middle School Teachers en
dc.subject COBRA en
dc.title Middle school ELL and LD teachers' perceptions of the importance of reading methods en
dc.type Dissertation en
dc.description.degree Doctor of Philosophy en
dc.description.level Doctoral en
dc.description.department Secondary Education en
dc.description.advisor Charles E. Heerman en
dc.subject.umi Education, Curriculum and Instruction (0727) en
dc.date.published 2007 en
dc.date.graduationmonth December en

Files in this item

This item appears in the following Collection(s)

Show simple item record

Search K-REx

Advanced Search


My Account


Center for the

Advancement of Digital